• Latest
The Importance Of Making A Proper Will

Comparing the US Supreme Court and the CCJ

6 years ago
CEO at MNIB resigns 

CEO at MNIB resigns 

1 hour ago
Statement by Minister Simon Stiell at Ministerial Roundtable on Climate

Simon Stiell set to be appointed UN climate chief

4 hours ago
Ministry of Culture to finance Groovy/Soca finalists’ stage presentations

Minister for Culture congratulates carnival winners

4 hours ago
MNIB postharvest handling training

MNIB announces CEO’s resignation

4 hours ago
Harbour Master statement on the incident involving Anderson Peters

Harbour Master statement on the incident involving Anderson Peters

20 hours ago
Kirani, Anderson and Victor shine at World Champs 2022

Significant number of people involved in investigation

21 hours ago
No Holiday for Carriacou Carnival

Statement on altercation involving Anderson Peters and others

21 hours ago
Tropical Weather Outlook: Thursday, 11 August 2022 (2 pm)

Tropical Weather Outlook: Thursday, 11 August 2022 (2 pm)

1 day ago
SDTB: Altercation involving Track Blazer member

SDTB: Altercation involving Track Blazer member

1 day ago
New National Party 2020 Christmas Message

NNP statement: Anderson Peters

1 day ago
World javelin champ thrown overboard from Harbour Master in Grenada

World javelin champ thrown overboard from Harbour Master in Grenada

1 day ago
Claims of coronavirus at SGU designed to create fear and panic

Covid-19 update: Grenada Dashboard 10 August 2022

1 day ago
NOW Grenada
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
NOW Grenada
No Result
View All Result

Comparing the US Supreme Court and the CCJ

This story was posted 6 years ago
17 February 2016
in OPINION/COMMENTARY
3 min. read
Sir Lawrence A Joseph
Share

by Sir Lawrence A Joseph

The recent passing of United States Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia helps to lay focus on the politicization of the judicial system in that country. The body of Justice Scalia who died on Saturday, 13 February last, may have been still warm when public debate regarding his replacement ensued. Key members of the Republican Party appear to be taking the position that President Obama, from the Democratic Party, should not go ahead and appoint a replacement for Justice Scalia on the Supreme Court. They are insisting that any new appointment should wait for some time after the inauguration of a new President scheduled for 20 January 2017. A new President is due to be elected on 8 November 2016. Comparing the process of the selection of judges to the US Supreme Court and the process of selection to the Caribbean Court of Justice is most intuitive.

It is popularly accepted that the decisions of the US Supreme Court depend on the ideological views of the usual 9 Justices of that court.  Those views are categorized as being either conservative, moderate or liberal philosophies of law and judicial interpretation. Whilst moderate views tend to take a middle road, on one end of the spectrum there are the conservative views which tend to be reluctant to change and usually stick with the status quo. For example, Justice Scalia was generally regarded as being a conservative. In fact, his approach to interpreting constitutional issues was based upon what he perceived to be the intention of the originators of the US constitution. On the other end of the spectrum, liberal views tend to “tweak” the constitution in such a way as to comply with modern-day opinions. Liberal views ruled the day in the case of Obergefell v Hodges (2015) when the Supreme Court held in a 5 to 4 decision that same-sex couples have a right to become married to each other.

According to Article 111 of the US Constitution, all Justices of the US Supreme Court, which is the final court of appeal in the US, must be nominated by the incumbent President of the country and such nominations have to be confirmed by the Senate. Historically, most Presidents nominate candidates who broadly share their ideological views. In general, therefore, Republican Presidents nominate conservative-minded candidates and Democratic Presidents nominate liberal-minded candidates. As a consequence of this trend, Republicans are concerned that incumbent President Obama would have the tendency to nominate a liberal-minded candidate, which nomination would go against their philosophical way of thinking. Seemingly, therefore, if President Obama goes ahead and nominates someone, that nomination would be blocked as the Republicans control the majority in the Senate.

The situation regarding the appointments of Judges to the Caribbean Court of Justice, which is the highest court of appeal for at least 4 Caricom states for the time being (i.e. Barbados, Guyana, Belize and Dominica), is very much different. Judges are neither nominated nor appointed by politicians. In fact, they are completely insulated from the political sphere. Judges of the CCJ are appointed by a Regional Judicial and Legal Services Commission, which was established pursuant to Article V (1) of the Agreement which established the CCJ. That Commission is completely independent of political influences. It comprises of 11 members who represent various groups throughout the region. These groups include Bar Associations, Judicial Services Commissions, Public Service Commissions, Civil Society, and Distinguished Jurists. Before the President of the Court is appointed a recommendation must come from the Commission.

Yet another institution which ensures that there is the independence of the CCJ from any political influences is the CCJ Trust Fund. This Fund started off with US$100 million with a loan from the Caribbean Development Bank and it is hoped that it will be income-generating to perpetuity. This arrangement helps to keep the court from depending on any largesse and from any administrative control by governments. The Fund is operated by a 9-member Board of Trustees comprising a group of independent professionals, which includes the Secretary-General of Caricom, the Vice-Chancellor of the University of the West Indies, the President of the Caribbean Association of Industry and Commerce and the President of the Caribbean Congress of Labour. Unlike the situation regarding the US Supreme Court, therefore, the CCJ is completely devoid of political influences.

NOW Grenada is not responsible for the opinions, statements or media content presented by contributors. In case of abuse, click here to report.
Tags: antonin scaliaccjconservativeconstitutionconstitutionallycourtjusticelawlawrence josephliberalsupreme court
Next Post
Closure: St George’s Health Centre

Zika Testing Lab has Arrived

© NOW Grenada. All Rights Reserved. Published by Aqua Design Inc. | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us

Copyright NOW Grenada

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings. Visit our Privacy Policy | Terms of Use.

Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. Visit our Privacy Policy | Terms of Use.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.