• Latest
Preliminary Results of 2013 General Election

Oliver Benoit on Grenadian ‘Reasons of State’

2 years ago
Harbour Master statement on the incident involving Anderson Peters

Harbour Master statement on the incident involving Anderson Peters

16 hours ago
Kirani, Anderson and Victor shine at World Champs 2022

Significant number of people involved in investigation

16 hours ago
No Holiday for Carriacou Carnival

Statement on altercation involving Anderson Peters and others

17 hours ago
Tropical Weather Outlook: Thursday, 11 August 2022 (2 pm)

Tropical Weather Outlook: Thursday, 11 August 2022 (2 pm)

20 hours ago
SDTB: Altercation involving Track Blazer member

SDTB: Altercation involving Track Blazer member

21 hours ago
New National Party 2020 Christmas Message

NNP statement: Anderson Peters

21 hours ago
World javelin champ thrown overboard from Harbour Master in Grenada

World javelin champ thrown overboard from Harbour Master in Grenada

21 hours ago
Claims of coronavirus at SGU designed to create fear and panic

Covid-19 update: Grenada Dashboard 10 August 2022

21 hours ago
Ministry of Youth Development congratulates Anderson Peters

Party boat crew members detained following assault of sportsman Anderson Peters

23 hours ago

Support extended for Comprehensive Disaster Management Project in Caribbean

1 day ago
20-man squad for CFU U14 Boys Challenge Series

20-man squad for CFU U14 Boys Challenge Series

1 day ago
Sandals Grenada: Now Hiring

Sandals Grenada: Multiple positions available

1 day ago
NOW Grenada
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
NOW Grenada
No Result
View All Result

Oliver Benoit on Grenadian ‘Reasons of State’

This story was posted 2 years ago
28 January 2021
in OPINION/COMMENTARY, Politics
4 min. read
Grenada Map
Share

by Eric Malczewski

In a lecture entitled “The Nation State and Economic Policy” delivered in 1895, Max Weber, a promising young economic historian who later would become a towering figure of 20th- and 21st Century social science, advanced the argument that the “reasons of state” which must govern the political interests of his native Germany first and foremost must be guided by a criterion of value that is essentially national.

The nation, as the locus of ultimate value (i.e. the supreme value to which state policy in its international, domestic, and economic dimensions, etc. is subservient), constitutes the legitimate source of political interests. In this conception, the nation is the central object of fidelity for the state or government. Weber’s main contention is that state policy must be effected and advanced in the interests of the nation.

As Professor Oliver Benoit argues, however, in his recently published work “Ressentiment, Nationalism and the Emergence of Political Culture in Grenada” (Pp. 100-115 in Research Handbook on Nationalism. Edited by Liah Greenfeld and Zeying Wu. Oxford: Edward Elgar. DOI:10.4337/9781789903447.00016) the presupposition of the primacy of the nation is not one that can be said to hold for all states. Benoit advances the striking claim that such a presupposition does not apply to the case of Grenada. He contends that the driving force of political decision making in Grenada is located in the interests of particularistic identities rooted in conceptions of race, class, and status as opposed to a national identity rooted on a conception of the fundamental equality of the Grenadian people. The historical consequence of particularistic identities being the focus of state policy is and has been an inability on the part of political leaders to understand political, economic, and social problems outside of particularistic (i.e. race-, class-, or status-based) frames of reference.

Benoit’s argument has 2 major dimensions: a theoretical claim bearing on the explanation of the sources and currents of politically relevant identities, and a substantive claim concerning the qualities of Grenadian political culture. As it regards the first dimension, Benoit advances an argument about the cultural basis of status order that situates his argument in the tradition of social theory focusing on the link between the historically specific categories through which people organise reality and orient their action and the motivational or psychological dynamics that empirically accompany use of these categories.

Benoit builds his theoretical case on the work of the luminaries Adam Smith, Friedrich Nietzsche, Max Scheler, Max Weber, W Arthur Lewis, and Liah Greenfeld. His most significant insight concerns the manner in which categories of race, class, and status helped foster particularistic identities (namely, identities that focused on the specific qualities of bounded groups) and, consequently, access to prestige was closely guarded. He argues that the psychological dynamic of ressentiment — a pernicious form of existential envy and yearning for recognition first identified by Nietzsche and later expanded upon in Scheler’s and Greenfeld’s scholarship — developed in the Grenadian middle class. This middle class recognised and internalised the principle of equality espoused by the colonial elite, yet they were denied the experience and attendant dignity of that equality on account of their race. The second major dimension of Benoit’s argument is the substantive claim that particularistic identities in Grenada flourished, and the ideal of equality — the fundamental quality of nationalist identity — did not take root there.

Benoit contends that Grenada’s particularistic identities endure and that to regard a putative Grenadian nationalism as a central form of identity or the Grenadian nation as the ultimate end of political decision making is historically inaccurate. This insight not only has implications for the study of Caribbean politics but also for the understanding of the consequences and fate of colonialism there. He claims that in Grenada, politics has been more about personality, as political figures struggle with status inconsistencies resulting from Grenada’s historical and cultural circumstances. Politicians whose experiences are shaped by these historical circumstances find it difficult to reconcile their status inconsistencies, and, consequently, the idea of focusing on the interest of the nation as a whole has been difficult. (111)

In Max Weber’s language, the “reasons of state” that typically guide political action in Grenada are not oriented to national interests, to the general interests of the Grenadian people understood as the locus of ultimate value or supreme object of political exertion. Professor Benoit’s scholarship illuminates key characteristics of politics and political culture whilst holding a mirror up to Grenadian society that shows it what criteria of value govern their political fate.

Eric Malczewski is an Assistant Professor, Centre for Public Administration and Policy, Virginia Tech Faculty Fellow, Centre for Cultural Sociology, Yale University.

Oliver Benoit, PhD, MFA is a Professor of Sociology, Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, St George’s University, Grenada. 

NOW Grenada is not responsible for the opinions, statements or media content presented by contributors. In case of abuse, click here to report.
Tags: eric malczewskinational identityOliver Benoitreasons of state
Next Post
GTAWU fears possible job losses following acquisition of Scotiabank

Unions heightening protest in anticipation of Government breach of agreement

Comment on post Cancel reply

Please enter your valid email address.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

© NOW Grenada. All Rights Reserved. Published by Aqua Design Inc. | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Categories
    • General News
      • All
      • Agriculture & Fisheries
      • Arts & Culture
      • Business
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • History
      • Lifestyle
      • Law
      • Politics
      • Technology
      • Travel & Tourism
      • Weather
      • Youth
    • Sports
      • All
      • Athletics
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Watersports
    • Community
      • All
      • Tribute
    • Crime
    • Features
      • All
      • Today in History
    • Opinion/Commentary
    • Press Releases
      • All
      • Advertisements
      • Notices
  • Video
  • Notices & Vacancies
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us

Copyright NOW Grenada

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings. Visit our Privacy Policy | Terms of Use.

Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. Visit our Privacy Policy | Terms of Use.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.